Wednesday 11 December 2013

Battle of the Managers - Pellegrini, Pardew, Poyet, Pochettino and Pulis

Have you heard the one about the Englishman, Welshman, Chilean, Argentine and Uruguayan? We don’t have a punch line for it yet but each of them are making their own headlines in the English Premier League this season.

It’s probably fair to say that Manuel Pellegrini has the biggest job – at least in terms of expectation levels – with a Manchester City team that underwhelmed in the league last season (after being triumphant the year before) and totally flopping in the Champions League. Phase one of Pellegrini’s plan has already been accomplished with City finally reaching the knock-out phase of the Champions League. However, in the Premier League, there is a little more work to be done. At the Etihad Stadium, they have looked every inch title contenders and are scoring goals galore but on their travels they have won just 2 of 8 games.

Tony Pulis is both the newest manager to join the Premier League battle this season and perhaps the most experienced. He led Stoke City to promotion from the Championship in 2008 and turned the Potters into a team that were really difficult to beat, especially at home. 5 seasons later and Stoke were still in the top flight and had enjoyed a season of European football but Pulis and the club parted ways at the end of the 2012/2013 season. He has now taken on the unenviable task of trying to keep Crystal Palace in the Premier League after an abysmal start to the season under previous boss Ian Holloway. Pulis is no stranger to a relegation dogfight and if anyone can get those red and blue football scarves waving again, it’s probably him.

Many people predicted doom and gloom for Alan Pardew and Newcastle United this season but they currently sit just 4 points behind Liverpool in second place. It seems that Pardew doesn’t really have an average season at St James’ Park, it’s either really impressive or awful! Last season was pretty dire, so the Magpies seem to be running to form again this year with a really decent start. There are probably eruptions (Joe Kinnear?) waiting to happen though and a bad run could soon bring them all to the surface again.

Has Gus Poyet walked into a job that is going to prove to be beyond him? Steve Bruce, Martin O’ Neill and Paulo Di Canio have all flirted with relegation at the Stadium of Light in recent seasons and Poyet has inherited a really difficult situation at Sunderland, with a squad that isn’t really his. Just 2 wins in his first 8 league games in charge and the Black Cats are now rooted to the bottom of the league. Whereas Crystal Palace were probably simply hoping to stay up this season, for Sunderland fans, after money was spent in the summer, expectations were and still are much higher. A tough task for Mr Poyet!


Although plenty of money has been spent both during their ascent to the Premier League and their current 2 year stay, how many people genuinely thought there would be quite so much progress at Southampton FC? Many people felt that Nigel Adkins was hard-done by when sacked midway through their first season back in the top flight, but while there might still be some sympathy and appreciation for the great job he did, most Saints fans are now more than happy with their new man, Mauricio Pochettino. They are playing exciting attacking football, they are genuinely competing (on the pitch at least) with the big clubs and are perhaps now being seen as European hopefuls rather than relegation contenders.

No comments:

Post a Comment